Nov 14, 2024

Trump’s Election Victory Complicates Ongoing Criminal Cases

by Lawrence J. Tjan | Nov 10, 2024
Donald Trump speaking at a podium with American flags in the background. Photo Source: Brian Snyder/Reuters via lemonde.fr

Donald Trump’s victory over Vice President Kamala Harris in Tuesday’s election could significantly impact the federal and state criminal cases he faces, potentially putting the federal prosecutions on hold and ending them entirely. Special counsel Jack Smith is reportedly assessing how to proceed with the cases, given the Justice Department’s established policy against prosecuting a sitting president.

Trump’s status as president-elect brings a range of legal challenges. His win complicates a pending Manhattan state case in which he was convicted of falsifying business records related to hush-money payments. Under the current schedule, State Supreme Court Justice Juan Merchan is set to rule on a potential immunity-based dismissal next week, with sentencing tentatively scheduled for late November. The conviction carries no mandatory prison time, but Trump’s election to the presidency further dims any realistic prospect of incarceration.

“If it was unlikely he was going to jail prior to this, he’s never going to jail now,” said former Manhattan prosecutor John Spagna. “By the time he’s not president, he’s too old to be sentenced to jail for this type of offense.” Trump’s legal team may push for another delay, hoping to prevent him from appearing in court during his presidential transition.

The federal prosecutions are now also in limbo. Trump faces charges in Washington, D.C., related to his efforts to overturn the 2020 election, and in Florida over alleged mishandling of classified documents. In the D.C. case, Smith’s team has argued that Trump’s actions largely fell outside the scope of his presidential duties and thus lack immunity protections. But now, Trump’s attorneys are expected to argue that the president-elect should not be weighed down by criminal proceedings as he prepares to take office.

In the Florida case, Judge Aileen Cannon dismissed charges that Trump unlawfully retained classified documents at his South Florida estate, ruling that Smith’s appointment was unlawful. Smith’s team is appealing, but the appeal is unlikely to advance before Trump’s inauguration.

Trump’s Georgia case, involving alleged election interference, may also lose momentum due to his new political status. This case had already been slowed by state appeals over possible conflicts involving Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis. Observers now believe that even if this case is revived, Trump’s role as president could stall any further action.

Trump’s win revives a question that surfaced during his previous term: whether he could attempt a self-pardon on federal charges. Legal scholars note that while he theoretically has this power, a self-pardon would spark intense legal and political scrutiny.

Throughout his campaign, Trump criticized special counsel Smith and vowed to remove him from office immediately upon returning to the White House. His election now gives him that authority, and a Trump-led Justice Department could dismiss Smith and end both federal cases.

In July, the Supreme Court strengthened Trump’s legal position by granting him immunity over official acts, prompting Smith to narrow his original charges. Trump’s team may argue that further proceedings should be postponed during the transition, and if unresolved by Inauguration Day, his assumption of office could halt the federal cases until his presidency concludes.

Share This Article

If you found this article insightful, consider sharing it with your network.

Lawrence J. Tjan
Lawrence J. Tjan
Lawrence is an attorney with experience in corporate and general business law, complemented by a background in law practice management. His litigation expertise spans complex issues such as antitrust, bad faith, and medical malpractice. On the transactional side, Lawrence has handled buy-sell agreements, Reg D disclosures, and stock option plans, bringing a practical and informed approach to each matter. Lawrence is the founder and CEO of Law Commentary.

Related Articles

Donald Trump seated at a meeting table, addressing attendees.
A Trump self-pardon could make criminal charges more likely

The possibility of President Trump issuing a self-pardon has been under discussion since the beginning of his presidency. In the wake of the riots at the Capitol on January 6, 2021, that possibility once again flirts with becoming a reality. Any discussion of the president’s power to pardon has to... Read More »

Donald Trump walking away from a vehicle, with an Air Force officer in the background.
On January 22, will Trump Face a Mountain of Legal Woes?

A historic quandary will face the nation on January 21, 2021, as one president leaves office and another begins his own four-year term. Unlike previous departing presidents, however, Donald Trump will turn back into a private citizen while facing a mountain of legal battles that not only had been put... Read More »