A federal judge in New York dealt former President Donald Trump another setback in his effort to stop a suit by the woman who is accusing him of defamation after he denied raping her. His motions to add a new alternative defense and a counterclaim for violation of a New... Read More »
Trump's Lawyer Pushes U.S. Appeals Court to Bring Marketing Scam Civil Lawsuit to Confidential Arbitration
Donald Trump’s attorney Thomas McCarthy has requested a federal appeals court to halt a civil lawsuit accusing the president of targeting poor and working-class Americans in promoting a multi-tiered marketing scam.
The charges against the Trumps say they exploited their famous name to secretly benefit from unsuspecting lower-income investors. The case, Doe et al. v. Trump Corp. et al., alleges the Trumps made large profits by fraudulently encouraging poor or low-income people to invest in companies connected to the Trumps.
The four plaintiffs accuse Trump, his adult children Ivanka, Donald Jr. and Eric, plus affiliate family firms including the Trump Network, a vitamin marketing company and the Trump Institute, of promoting the marketing company American Communications Network (ACN) in exchange for hidden payments of millions of dollars.
The secret payments were allegedly made to the Trumps between 2005 and 2015.
The plaintiffs, including one hospice worker, said in their civil lawsuit that ACN charged them $499 for goods including video phones. They allege the Trump family tricked them into believing their investments would be profitable.
The civil lawsuit states Trump "told investors that he had 'experienced the opportunity’, ‘done a lot of research’ and that his endorsement was 'not for any money.’’’
U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield had already refused to send the case to arbitration in April, saying the four plaintiffs in the lawsuit had no reason to believe their arbitration agreements with ACN included the Trumps.
The Trumps are pushing for arbitration instead of a public civil lawsuit as brought by the plaintiffs. Many defendants prefer arbitration to litigation for numerous reasons, such as the proceedings remaining confidential.
In a new hearing before a panel of three judges in December, New York Circuit Judge Denny Chin agreed with the prior decision not to move to arbitration by Schofield. Chin said it was unfair to the plaintiffs to dismiss their lawsuit, especially since Trumps had already obtained the dismissal of racketeering claims in the lawsuit.
“You waited eight months before asking to compel arbitration,” said Chin. “You requested and obtained substantive relief. In those circumstances, why isn’t the right to arbitration, to the extent it exists, waived?”
Trump’s attorney disagreed, claiming he believes the charges are politically motived and that President Trump had expressed his own opinion on the investment while having no control over ACN.
The plaintiffs' lawyer, Roberta Kaplan, replied that arbitration is “fundamentally a matter of consent.”
“This is a fraud case,” said Kaplan. “This is about what Donald Trump said.”
Related Articles
New York Attorney General Letitia James shared new information in her new court filing last week about the ongoing civil investigation against former President Donald Trump, stating they had discovered “significant evidence” of his company’s using fraudulent valuations multiple times. James also stated in the court filings that evidence shows... Read More »
Former President Donald Trump is still fighting federal and civil lawsuits claiming he is the victim of political bias, this time over ongoing New York investigations launched in 2019 into his business practices and other matters. This week, Trump filed a lawsuit against New York State attorney general Letitia James.... Read More »
In 2019, Michael Cohen testified that the Trump Organization provided false values for property holdings as part of a scheme to obtain loans and avoid taxes. Cohen’s role in protecting the President caused the attorney to serve time in prison. Now, New York’s Attorney General’s office is conducting a probe... Read More »